Nike deep-dive: Is it a falling knife or a bargain?
We have seen a lot of increasing interest (at least in the Q&A section of TF) in Nike, as its price recently went to a 10-year low. In this note, we try to answer the question of whether NKE is worth looking at now and, if so, at which price.
The case here is relatively straightforward: one of the world's biggest brands is struggling. If Nike manages to turn its fortunes around, a long-term investor could potentially benefit substantially, assuming a reasonable entry price. But if the turnaround fails, what could the downside look like, and what should a reasonable investor expect overall?
There has been a lot of negative news around Nike, and some of it (related mostly to the stock price) is self-enforcing: the lower it gets, the worse the publicity becomes. The stock has recently been removed from the S&P 100 following a significant decrease in market cap. Although this is indeed not good news, as Nike would no longer automatically be part of some passive ETF purchases, we prefer to ignore it in our analysis below.
The reason is simple: as Peter Lynch famously observed, in the long run, stock prices follow earnings, not news. If Nike succeeds in its turnaround efforts, its share price should eventually reflect that success.
One important caveat is that turning around a struggling large business is extremely difficult. There are plenty of examples of major consumer brands that lost their competitive edge due to changing consumer preferences, technology, marketing strategies or other factors — and simply never managed to recover.
So, let’s have a closer look.
Where Is Nike Now – What Happened to its Business Performance, Stock Price and Market Cap?
Ironically, Nike is now struggling as a result of implementing a strategy that investors initially liked. Following the COVID pandemic, the company focused a significant part of its resources on developing its direct-to-consumer channel (essentially, betting on online purchases through its website and apps) and pulling back from traditional offline third-party retailers.
The idea was simple on paper: consumer habits had shifted towards online shopping, and this would allow Nike to cut out the middleman, reduce distribution costs and refocus its marketing spend on its own channels, thereby increasing its margins and earnings.
At first, it appeared to work. In 2021, Nike posted its strongest results: revenue grew 19.1% year over year, the company reported record net income of $5.7B, its highest net income margin on record of 12.9%, and its highest free cash flow of $5.9B. Investors cheered: the stock price rose from $91 per share at the beginning of 2020 to $152 per share by the end of 2021. They were also pricing in further growth. In 2021, Nike's average P/E multiple was around 37x, implying expected annual earnings growth of approximately 14%, based on Benjamin Graham's intrinsic value formula.
However, subsequent business results did not live up to initial expectations. It turned out that traditional offline distribution channels were still important, consumers were not ready to go all-in on online shopping, and China (one of Nike's major markets) experienced a significant slowdown. On top of that, Nike's controversial marketing and its overall shift in marketing strategy from a sports-led approach to a more general one were probably mistakes.
As Peter Lynch famously observed, in the long run, stock prices follow earnings, not news:
It is well known that when a relatively mature company trades at a very high P/E multiple, with no obvious drivers of significant earnings growth beyond the organic performance of its business, even a modest slowdown in growth can trigger a substantial decline in its share price and market capitalisation.
This is exactly what happened to Nike. In 2022, earnings per share growth started to slow, and in 2023, margins declined, resulting in lower EPS than in 2022. The stock price fell, but many investors still viewed this as a temporary setback and a buying opportunity.
Nike gave them some reason for optimism: the business performed relatively steadily in 2024. However, in 2025 and 2026, things took a dramatic turn. Nike's revenue declined substantially from its 2024 levels, leading to a sharp deterioration in margins and earnings per share.
As a result, fiscal year 2026 EPS fell to approximately $2.20, the same level as in 2016. In other words, Nike has effectively gone back 10 years in terms of earnings — but with one important difference: back in 2016, it was a growing business; today, it is struggling with declining revenue.
In other words, it is no longer just about margins or growth; it is about the overall health of the business and demand for Nike's products. When a major company's revenue drops by almost 10% in a single year (as Nike's did in 2025), it is clear that the business is struggling.
What Is Nike's Overall Business Quality, and Can It Restore Its Growth Going Forward?
When a business faces problems of this scale (and losing $6B in revenue while seeing earnings fall to a 10-year low is a huge blow), the key question to consider before looking at turnaround efforts is whether the company has sufficient liquidity to get through this period without having to dilute existing shareholders.
The good news is that Nike appears well-positioned to weather the storm. Despite the significant deterioration in its business performance in 2026, it remained free cash flow positive, while its net debt stood at a relatively modest $4.1B, leaving room for further borrowing if needed.
This means that, at least for now, existing shareholders have reasonable grounds to believe that Nike will not need to raise additional equity capital and dilute their ownership.
Looking at its P&L and cash flow statement, Nike's margins have been relatively modest recently (Q1 FY2027 net income margin of 6.4%). However, its CAPEX requirements are also relatively low. In other words, Nike's financial situation remains relatively stable, giving the company time to execute its turnaround efforts.
The big question is how far revenue will decline before it eventually bottoms out. On its latest conference call, the company provided its guidance for fiscal 2027, expecting revenue to decline in the high single-digit range. We will use this as our starting point for 2027 in the forecast below.
So, what exactly is Nike doing to turn its business around? The company has changed its CEO and announced several initiatives:
- "Sport Offense" strategy: Focuses on aligning products with distinct consumer segments and enhancing local market relevance.
- "Pace" program: The company is restructuring its operating model to improve efficiency and decision-making while reducing costs.
- Greater China digital marketplace: Nike is continuing its efforts to clean up its digital marketplace in Greater China, where revenue declined by 26% in the latest quarter, with the aim of improving the retail experience. The company expects these efforts to take multiple seasons to deliver results.
- Sportswear revitalization: The company is focusing on revitalizing its Sportswear business by breaking it down into smaller segments tailored to specific consumer insights.
All of this sounds like the right steps to us. Nike still owns some of the best brands in the world, and we believe it could successfully execute its turnaround strategy. However, given the scale of the business and the severity of the decline in China, it seems that the turnaround could take several years to complete.
What Is Nike's Fair Value, and What Would Be a Reasonable Entry Price for a Long-Term Investor?
We do not see a quick fix to Nike's problems. Anyone considering Nike as an investment should have a time horizon of at least five years to allow the company to complete its turnaround.
An exception would be a speculative trade, targeting a quick sale once the share price rises on the back of positive news. We would caution readers against this approach, however, as such price movements are not necessarily supported by improvements in business performance. By default, this type of trade relies on volatility and carries significant downside risk.
Consider investing in Nike only if you have the time and patience to wait for the turnaround to materialise.
Our base-case forecast is as follows:
- Revenue: Falls by 8% in fiscal 2027, declines by a further 3% in 2028, remains flat in 2029 and starts recovering at 3% annually from 2030 onwards.
- Net income margin: Remains at 6.7% in 2027, increases to 8% in 2028 and then to 9.7% in 2029 and beyond.
- Cash from operations: Remains at 6.2% of revenue in 2027, increasing to 7%, 9%, 10% and subsequently 11.1% in 2028–2031, with 11.1% representing the historical average.
- CAPEX: Decreases by 5% annually, reaching $502M per year by 2031.
- Free cash flow: Free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) reaches $1.9B in 2027 and grows steadily to $4.3B by 2031.
- The company is not issuing additional stock to go throgh the turnaround.
We also incorporate a margin of safety by applying a 10% required rate of return and a relatively modest 3% terminal growth rate in the Gordon Growth Model. In our view, this results in a relatively conservative forecast, producing an estimated value of $32.70 per share, which we consider a potential entry point for a long-term investor.
We deliberately do not assume significant revenue growth in our forecast, and there is a reason for this. When investing in a turnaround, simply getting the business back to where it was before is essentially job done (and this is the scenario we are modelling). If the company manages to achieve additional growth on top of that, it represents an opportunity for further returns. However, given the difficulty of forecasting such growth, we believe it should not be included in the base-case scenario.
As for when to invest, it is better not to try to catch the bottom. We like Stephen Schwarzman's approach to timing market cycles and turnarounds, which is to wait for the rebound. Specifically, you should only invest after asset values have recovered by at least 10–15% from their lows. We would add that this should also be supported by business results. In Nike's case, there should be reliable signs that the revenue decline is slowing and that revenue is stabilising, as well as evidence that the company is making progress with its turnaround efforts.
One final note of caution: we do not expect our base-case scenario to be precise. As with financial modelling of all sorts, one thing is certain: in any given year, you are most likely to be wrong. What we do expect, though, is that Nike will, on average, perform broadly in line with our forecast over the next several years on a cumulative free cash flow basis. Thus, we believe this forecast should serve as a useful reference point when considering an investment in Nike.
**
**
Our verdict
Nike`s TopFunds Business quality rank: 5.7 / 10.
Nike could be interesting investment for a long-term investor with at least 5 year time horizon and who is able to withstand significant volatility. Our potential entry price would be around $30-33 per share.